Every e-commerce store owner knows how irritating bots and spammers can be, and how serious fraudulent activities may compromise users’ data, all leading to reputational losses, reduced trust, and leaving clients.
On the other hand, everyone who has ever ordered anything or filled out any form on any website knows how annoying reCAPTCHA forms can be, popping up every minute and asking you to confirm being a human, causing nothing but a desire to leave the site.
In this guide, we’ll explore the two solutions, MageСomp Google reCAPTCHA and Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha, that help both Magento 2 merchants and their customers not to suffer from bots and the consequences they cause. We’ll compare each provider’s module, pointing out key features and differences. All that’s left for you is to read it and choose the option that you find a better match.
Why reCAPTCHA Matters in E-commerce?
Magento 2 e-commerce store owners or their website moderators may spend hours cleaning up sites to block spam. Besides, merchants also have to keep top-level security to avoid bots that might steal customers’ data and harm business with malicious or junk requests on the website. Magento 2 reCAPTCHA extensions play a significant role in keeping the store protected from fraudulent activities, malicious bots, and spam, preventing them from compromising your Magento 2 store's security, customer data, and overall user experience and reputation.
reCAPTCHA helps prevent fraudulent transactions, such as false account creation, payment fraud, or scamming by blocking bots’ activity from abusing the system, protecting sensitive customer and payment data. Plus, e-commerce stores typically have contact forms, reviews, and product inquiries where bots can submit spam messages or fake reviews. reCAPTCHA helps ensure that only real customers submit these forms, maintaining the credibility of your brand.
In addition to the obvious benefits described above, reCAPTCHA helps maintain site security and data integrity, ultimately improving the trustworthiness of your Magento 2 store. This leads to higher customer trust and increased conversion rates, as well as proves security in the eyes of search engines, which can add to search engine rankings, helping you attract more organic traffic.
What is MageСomp Google reCAPTCHA?
MageComp Google reCAPTCHA is an extension that adds Google reCAPTCHA to boost security against spambots, robots, fraudulent activities, and abuse. The extension integrates Google reCAPTCHA with different types of pages and web forms, such as product review or newsletter subscription, making sure that only real, verified customers can access data, which prevents fake activities and maintains store security.
What is Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha?
Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha for Magento 2 is a powerful security module designed to protect your online store from spam, bots, and malicious activity while maintaining a seamless user experience. Unlike traditional CAPTCHA solutions, the invisible reCAPTCHA works automatically in the background, allowing legitimate customers to complete forms, checkout, or account registration without interruption. Besides, Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha allows showing reCAPTCHA only for guest users, offering authorized customers a seamless experience with pages.
The module enables Magento 2 merchants to secure all forms on the website, including login, registration, contact, and newsletter subscription forms. It helps prevent automated spam submissions and fraudulent activities, safeguarding both customer data and store integrity.
Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha stands out from other solutions by offering easy configuration, flexible form selection, custom forms protection, and support for multiple store views. Merchants can customize the module to suit their specific needs without affecting the website’s performance or user experience.
For Magento 2 store owners, the module not only enhances security and trustworthiness but also contributes to a smoother, more professional shopping experience. By blocking bots invisibly, it ensures that customers can interact with the site effortlessly, while administrators gain peace of mind knowing the store is protected from unwanted automated activity.
Read More: Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha Guide
Key Features Comparison: MageСomp Google reCaptcha vs. Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha
Key Features | MageComp Google reCAPTCHA | |
Compatibility with reCaptcha v3 | ✅ | ✅ |
ReCaptcha themes | ✅ | ✅ |
Compatibility with Non-JavaScript browsers | ❌ | ✅ |
ReCaptcha for guests only | ✅ | ❌ |
Custom reCaptcha message | ✅ | ❌ |
IP whitelist | ✅ | ❌ |
Custom language of reCaptcha | ✅ | ❌ |
Custom reCaptcha button location | ✅ | ❌ |
Custom forms protection | ✅ | ❌ |
Protection of the Contact Us form | ✅ | ✅ |
Protection of the Customer Registration form | ✅ | ✅ |
Protection of the Product Review form | ✅ | ✅ |
Protection of the Forgot Password form | ✅ | ✅ |
Protection of the Checkout Registration form | ❌ | ✅ |
Protection of the Newsletter Subscription form | ✅ | ✅ |
Protection of the Customer Login form | ✅ | ❌ |
Protection of the Change Password form | ✅ | ❌ |
Protection of the Checkout Payments form | ✅ | ❌ |
Hyvä Theme compatibility | ✅ | ✅ |
Cut the total cost of ownership of all your extensions in half — switch to Amasty Only products today!
Features of MageComp Google reCAPTCHA for Magento 2
Compatibility with reCaptcha v3
The Google reCAPTCHA extension by MageComp includes the most basic functionality that you may need. First off, it integrates the latest Google reCAPTCHA version 3 with your Magento store via API. Thus, you can protect your store from spambots. The reCAPTCHA can identify whether you are a robot or a human without any additional steps. The user needs to pass a CAPTCHA only if the system considers the activity suspicious.
Protection of default Magento 2 forms
You can enable the MageComp reCAPTCHA on the following Magento 2 forms:
Contact Us
Customer Registration
Product Review
Forgot Password
Checkout Registration
Newsletter Subscription
Compatibility with non-JavaScript browsers
If the visitor uses a browser that does not support JavaScript, or it was disabled manually, the extension will still work and protect your store.
Light and dark reCAPTCHA theme
This extension comes with 2 design themes: dark and light, so you can choose the most suitable one. Besides, the module is compatible with the Hyvä Theme.
Features of Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha for Magento 2
Basic features
As well as MageComp, Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha extension supports all the basic features like:
Compatibility with Google reCAPTCHA versions 2 and 3
Different design themes
Hyvä Theme compatibility
Protection of default Magento forms:
Customer Create Account
Customer Login
Newsletter Subscription
Contact Us
Customer Forgot Password
Product Review
Change Password
Checkout Payments
But besides all these features, it includes some advanced functionality.
ADA & WCAG compliance
Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha is compliant with ADA & WCAG standards, ensuring accessibility and legal compliance.
Show reCAPTCHA only for guests
With this extension, you can disable reCAPTCHA for registered users and improve their user experience.
Display custom reCAPTCHA message
You can customize the message users see if they haven’t passed the reCAPTCHA test. With a clear and user-friendly explanation, you will prevent the growth of your website abandonment.
IP whitelist
If you have a distributed team that works from different places around the globe, you can apply the IP whitelist feature. By adding your employees’ IP addresses to the special field in the backend, you will disable reCAPTCHA for them.
Advanced design options
Besides the 2 themes of the Captcha badge, this extension supports advanced design features. For example, by default, the extension uses the same language as is set in the browser to display the reCAPTCHA badge, but you can customize the default language in the admin panel.
Also, you can change the reCAPTCHA button location on the page for each store view.
Custom forms protection
If you use any custom forms, you can protect them with the Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha. For this, you need to fill in their URLs and CSS selectors in the corresponding fields in the admin panel.
When to Choose Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha Over MageComp Google reCAPTCHA
Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha for Magento 2 suits your e-commerce Magento 2 store if you need advanced customization, better user experience for registered users, custom form protection, IP whitelisting, and flexible badge placement.
Here are the benefits of Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha:
Advanced UX control: If you want to disable reCAPTCHA for registered users, Amasty allows showing it only to guests. This improves the shopping experience for returning customers without compromising security, boosting client retention and satisfaction.
Customizable reCAPTCHA messages: Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha lets you display custom messages if a user fails the CAPTCHA test, making it more user-friendly and reducing potential website abandonment.
IP whitelisting for teams: For distributed teams or internal users who frequently access the backend, Amasty allows you to whitelist IPs, so employees are not challenged by reCAPTCHA
Advanced design: Beyond the standard light and dark themes, Amasty lets you customize the badge language and change the button location per store view, giving greater control over branding and multilingual stores.
Custom forms protection: If your store uses custom forms beyond the default Magento 2 forms, Amasty allows you to protect them.
Flexible reCAPTCHA version support: Amasty Google Invisible reCaptcha supports both Google reCAPTCHA v2 and v3, offering more flexibility depending on your store’s security needs.
To Sum It Up
Amasty and MageComp both offer powerful reCAPTCHA solutions to protect Magento 2 stores from bots, spammers, and malicious activity without affecting the shopping experience for trusted users. Both providers cover the reCAPTCHA basics like standard form protection, Google reCAPTCHA v3 support, and design customization, allowing you to safeguard your website and clients’ sensitive data.
MageComp may be a nice choice for smaller websites without many custom forms and a smaller client base. The Amasty solution will better suit the owners of bigger Magento 2 stores, offering greater customizability, more form protection, and discarding reCAPTCHA for authorized users, which helps reduce friction and provide smoother customer experiences while keeping the data safe.
Choose the option that best fits your current business needs and that will keep your e-commerce store safe in the future.
